The Enid News and Eagle, Enid, OK

Militant Moderate

March 10, 2010

Broken government



In particular, the republicans have taken advantage of Senate rules adopted during an earlier period of gentlemanly political chivalry in relationships and conduct styles.  To work, Senate rules depend on common courtesy, decency, and a code of honor among gentlemen (and ladies).  Without common courtesies and mutual respect, the Senate becomes hamstrung by its own rules and is unable to perform its duties of governance for the people.  When one party’s constituency abandons this code, then the other cannot continue to abide by it and be effective.  This is what has occurred. 


The rule regarding sixty votes for cloture (closing debate, cutting off a filibuster, and bringing an issue to a vote) may not have always been the bad thing that it is now.  When parties and members were restrained, and the threat of a filibuster was rare, it may have been helpful in slowing a few actions for greater deliberation.  But it is poison in this partisan environment. 


The 60 vote rule in the Senate is antithetical to democracy, where a majority must rule.  It is counterproductive to the functioning of our American democracy, and it should be scrapped immediately.  It has “broken” our Senate, and rendered it dysfunctional. 


There is another Senate rule which is even worse, and must also be scrapped immediately.  This is the rule that allows a single senator to hold up consideration of a bill or a presidential appointment.  This rule, borne in that period of political chivalry and excess courtesy, is being grossly abused.  A single senator can thwart the will of not only the Senate majority but the entire Congress and the nation.  This has been happening regularly. 


Our own two senators from Oklahoma have used this frequently, as a matter of personal privilege and arrogance, to hold up actions of the entire Senate, therefore the government.  Senator Coburn’s offices have been picketed by crowds of interested Oklahoma young people over his hold on humanitarian aid to an oppressed people in Africa.  Earlier he held up money for veterans’ health care, citing his same “principle.” 

Text Only
Militant Moderate
  • Mugwump on Arizona

    How many of us one-time history scholars recall the term “mugwump?”

    May 12, 2010

  • Gleanings frm cyber world

    Some of the material encountered in cyber space, either floated or directed by messaging, is quite airy, amusing, or really funny.  Other material is quite inspirational.  Still other gleanings prove to be informative and educational. 

    May 6, 2010

  • The good, bad and ugly

    The bad and the ugly in state politics have been readily observable to the Oklahoma public, and lately even to the nation at large.  But the good has been more difficult to discern within the Oklahoma legislature.

    April 29, 2010

  • Tea Party Enigma

    April 26, 2010

  • Militia: Near and Far

    Recalling anti-tax rhetoric of the past

    April 20, 2010

  • Dr. No

    A few doctors give the impression that they think they are gods.  Nearly everyone has known one or two.  It appears that Oklahomans may have one of those as U. S. Senator. 

    April 13, 2010

  • The fringe of the tea wagon

    Two fringe movements have been spotlighted in the news lately.

    April 7, 2010

  • All Tea Party

    “We are all Tea Party here,” declared Sarah Palin appearing with John McCain at a recent rally supporting his re-election as senator from Arizona. 

    March 30, 2010

  • Health care myths

    Who has not heard the Republican rhetoric about the health care proposals in Congress?

    March 17, 2010

  • Broken government

    “Our government is broken,” say some politicians and pundits.  If indeed this condition exists, then its “breaking” must have been an event.

    March 10, 2010