The Enid News and Eagle, Enid, OK


November 24, 2012

Funny how this ended

ENID, Okla. — To hear Fred Stokes tell it, he got carried away “a mite” in a Kansas City press conference Aug. 10 with his explanation of a lawsuit against the U.S. Department of Agriculture and the Cattlemen’s Beef Board over the management of the beef checkoff.

Noting the Humane Society of the U.S. had done the legal digging to lay the foundation for the suit, Stokes said, “Every cowboy out there owes a deep debt of gratitude to the Humane Society of the U.S.” for its efforts to help the checkoff benefit all cattlemen.

It was vintage Stokes, a founder of the Organization for Competitive Markets: Anyone or anything that made markets work better was always welcome.

By the time he returned to his native Mississippi, however, he wasn’t welcome.

On Aug. 13, Stokes, a district director for Mississippi Farm Bureau Federation, was en route to a state directors meeting when MFBF President Randy Knight telephoned to say he wanted to see Stokes before the meeting.

“He made it clear that I had crossed some line when I acknowledged the checkoff lawsuit and HSUS’ role in it,” Stokes relates. “The board inferred that I had conspired with HSUS in the lawsuit and that was a ‘conflict of interest’ on my part because Farm Bureau supports checkoffs.”

The lawsuit asks USDA to run the checkoff according to its rules.

“Surely, you can’t be against something following its own rules,” Stokes said.

Little did he know how prescient that remark would become.

On Oct. 24, Mississippi Farm Bureau notified Stokes of an Oct. 29 hearing in Jackson to discuss two complaints filed by state board members over his “conflict of interest” with Farm Bureau policy. Stokes came, with two attorneys, ready for a fight.

One attorney, James Robertson, explained to Mississippi Farm Bureau board that its own bylaws did not permit it to remove Stokes from office. Then, Robertson, reinforced by J. Dudley Butler, an ag attorney from Yazoo City, Miss., explained the group’s bylaws required some “exchange of financial interest” for a conflict of interest charge to have merit.

“There’s nothing in this (checkoff) lawsuit that constitutes a transaction that Fred Stokes has with the Mississippi Farm Bureau Federation,” Robertson said.

The lawyers’ better knowledge of Farm Bureau’s own bylaws carried the day. The state board, though, not having the authority to remove Stokes, allowed Stokes’ Farm Bureau future to be determined by members of the three-county district board he chaired.

On Nov. 12, state president Randy Knight chaired a meeting in Meridian, to, as he explained, “decide if they wanted Mr. Stokes to continue to represent them.”

Whoa, not so, said Butler, again present at Stokes’ request. MFBF’s bylaws require “cause” for removal of a director, and the Jackson meeting clearly showed there was none.

Another attorney, Ricky Ruffin, said “… if we are not here for some kind of cause … are we saying that we are going to kick this man off because we don’t like the way he parts his hair?”

And that’s just what happened; the locals, acting in what Stokes and Butler claim was state-controlled vote, cashiered him by a 12-3 count, with two abstentions.

Stokes expected as much. He then quit because “I had proved just how phony their charges were.”

It’s a foolish victory because, using the standard they set, any one of the them could be next for nothing more than how they part their hair.

Or, of course, what they think.

© 2012 ag comm

Text Only
  • Jeff Bedwell Consider safety of forage beforehand

    Drought conditions of the past three to four years and in particular the past eight months had hay/forage inventories at critically low levels. The most recent period ranked as the third-driest period in recorded history. Not unlike the farmers and ranchers of other times of drought, ag producers now have been very resourceful to not only replace hay supplies that have dwindled but also add much-needed revenue to farm income.

    July 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Right to Farm web 1.jpg Ag industry seeks right to farm

    The emerging battle could have lasting repercussions for the nation’s food supply and for the millions of people worldwide who depend on U.S. agricultural exports. It’s also possible the right-to-farm idea could sputter as a merely symbolic gesture that carries little practical effect beyond driving up voter turnout in local elections.

    July 19, 2014 2 Photos

  • farm - Burlington FFA web.jpg Burlington students attend camp

    More than 1,600 FFA members from 289 Oklahoma FFA chapters attended one of four three and one-half day sessions from June 29-July 12.

    July 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • farm - Oklahoma's Dirty Dozen poster 150dpi_W.jpg Poster targets invasive plants

    They all have more than four letters, but they are certainly bad words in the state of Oklahoma.

    July 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • farm - Rick Nelson web.jpg Simple steps can prevent fungus infection

    July 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • Help plants survive the summer heat

    The July hot weather has arrived, and Oklahoma State University has some suggestions for helping with our gardening needs this month.

    July 12, 2014

  • farm - 4-H_W_W.jpg State 4-H honors volunteers

    A group of dedicated parents and volunteers with Oklahoma 4-H Youth Development Program gathered recently in Stillwater for learning, sharing of ideas and recognition of dedication to Oklahoma’s youth.

    July 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • Danna Zook cutout web.jpg Water quality important for livestock

    Even though many areas have been blessed with ample rain this past month, we must not brush aside issues resulting from the evident drought.

    June 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • Farm Poisoni_Hass web.jpg Poison tested to control hogs: Preservative used to cure bacon may be key to problem

    Hunting and trapping won’t do the trick for these big, wildly prolific animals. So, the U.S. Department of Agriculture kicked off a $20 million program this year to control feral swine, which have spread from 17 states in 1982 to 39 now.

    June 28, 2014 2 Photos

  • farm  - Junior Beef Ambassadors web.jpg Area youth place in beef ambassador contest

    Cash prizes were given to the top three contestants in each age division.

    June 28, 2014 2 Photos

Featured Ads